The Vision
Learn more about the paintings
Learn about the artist
Join in the discussion

Be a part of The Nativity Project

Purchase prints and cards

Contact The Nativity Project

 

Recasting the Magi BARBARA MARIAN


The Meeting of the Magi
The Limbourg Brothers
Painted prior to 1416
My love for the stories about the birth of Jesus began as soon as I could toddle up the aisle of my parish church and peek through the communion rail. Every Advent, I joined the other children, jostling to get a glimpse of the Christmas crib. Each Sunday, new figures appeared, heightening my anticipation of the holy birth. Even after spying the baby Jesus nestled in the manager on Christmas morning, when most of the kids thought the story was over, I continued my vigil, waiting for one more scene to unfold at the crib-the visit of the Magi.

These exotic, mysterious figures fascinated me. The story of their long journey across a vast desert, with only a star to guide them, made a deep impression on my imagination. I could see these kings, riding on their camels, following a twinkling star for thousands and thousands of miles. I could visualize their encounter with the Christ child, one kneeling close to Jesus and his mother, another standing back almost in shadow, and a third leaning over to get a better look as he held the reins of his camel, straining at the bit. One was dark-skinned; two had beards. All three wore splendid, flowing robes and glorious hats; a puffy purple velvet hat with a feather sticking straight up in the front, a crown with rubies on the points, and a deep blue silken baker's hat with a golden tassel swinging from the top. And what gifts they brought! Only rich and powerful kings from strange and faraway lands would bring gifts like these; a box of gold, a jar of costly incense, and a bottle of perfumed oil.

Imagine my surprise and delight when I learned that one of the kings shared my name: Kaspar! My family spelled it " Casper ," but that didn't matter. It was the same name, and that meant we might be related. The thought filled me with awe.

Years went by before I searched the Gospel of Matthew on my own and found repeated reference to "wise men from the east" ("astrologers" in some translations) - but no kings, no names, no specific number. This puzzled me until I learned about midrash (MID-rash), a type of story that is actually a commentary on another story. The Hebrew word midrash translates into English as "to search, inquire, and interpret." To engage in midrash means to give free play to the imagination, enlarging and embellishing the original story to reveal hidden insights. The story of the Magi as told in hymn, pageant, art, and theater surely qualifies as midrash . Through the centuries a brief Scripture story has grown into an elaborate tale. Does this mean we need not take it seriously? Heavens no!

Stories shape the way we think and feel, but we also have the power to shape and reshape them. This recasting goes on constantly and reflects our changing perspectives. Indeed, stories that become static lose their meaning for us. As a lifelong lover of the Epiphany story, I have observed some interesting shifts over the years, but lately I sense a groundswell of reinterpretations of this "classic" tale.

This past fall, a promotion tucked into an issue of AMERICA magazine caught my attention. The Jesuits were promoting gift subscriptions with a tear-out ad showing three figures kneeling before Jesus, who was seated on his mother's lap. They wore the ragged garb of shepherds. Last in line knelt a figure with an angular jaw and no sign of facial hair, probably a young male. The pose of the three worshipers strongly suggested the Magi; A prominent star shined overhead, Jesus looked older than newborn, and Joseph was absent from the scene. Below the picture, the caption read: "This Christmas, give a gift that will enrich and enlighten." All of this indicated that the artist was playing with - recasting - the people in this familiar, traditional scene of Magi adoring the Christ child.

A recent mailer from Liturgy Training Publications in Chicago featured its "Welcome, Yule!" poster for the upcoming season. The poster's depiction of the three Magi intrigued me. The most prominent figure, in the foreground, appeared to be a young person riding a horse or pony. This drawing went so far as to give one of the Magi androgynous features.

Last year at this time, in a reflection on the Epiphany readings for AMERICA, John R. Donahue SJ, related the story of a small boy who frowned with disappointment at the Christmas card renderings of the Magi and blurted out, "Where are the girls?" The Jesuit went on to suggest that by raising the question the child had "captured the meaning of Epiphany" - Christ for all people.

A humorous spin on the Epiphany story circulated on the Internet toward the end of 2000. The subject line read, "What if there were three wise women?" A long list of remarks followed: They would have asked directions, arrived on time, brought practical gifts, and so on.

What does all this mean? Is the Epiphany story about to be overhauled in the interest of political correctness? Are women invading the domain of the Three Kings? In all likelihood, they've been there all along. In The Birth of the Messiah (Doubleday, 1993), the definitive study of the infancy narratives of Matthew and Luke, author Raymond Brown suggests that we view the Epiphany story in the context of the journey accounts that dot the historical record of the first century Mediterranean world. He cites numerous examples of foreign dignitaries journeying from distant lands to pay homage. What group of powerful men would set out for a foreign land on official business without women along to provide the services and comforts required on a lengthy journey? The ancient storytellers had no need to make specific reference to the women because the listeners would have assumed their presence and deemed their contribution not worthy of mention.

It's easy to get so caught up in regal images of Matthew's night visitors that we miss the core message - Christ for all people. The story of the Magi in the Gospel of Matthew allowed the Jewish followers of Jesus to imagine the unthinkable - God's grace extending to the outsiders, the gentiles. Who are the outsiders in our world? Can we imagine the favor of God extending beyond the human boundaries of race, class, nationality, ethnicity, religious devotion, and gender? The Epiphany story portrays people on a journey in search of the truth and a glimpse of the divine, people "seeking God with a sincere heart" (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church, no. 16). If we recast the story of the Magi, who will play these seekers of the divine? Consider the possibilities: those without power or wealth, young people, women, Muslims. Let the midrash begin.

Barbara Marian at 5 years of age when she first experienced the hunger to find and see God.

The child in each one of us carries the deepest of human longings--to see God. This longing--indeed, this fear--is the basis of the religious impulse in human nature and all forms of religious expression.

Children the world over are fascinated by babies. They are drawn to them. They delight in them. This is true of little boys as well as little girls. The baby in the Christmas creche, glowing in the joy of adoring parents, captivates us. It is the Child calling to the child in each one of us.
The story of Christmas is perhaps the most treasured story of all because in it we sense something that calls us home to our center--to the deepest, most beautiful reality we can imagine--the Love we come to name "God."


The Adoration of the Kings
Pieter Bruegel the Elder, 1564


Read the story in scripture
Matthew 2:1-12


See traditional
Magi art here.